← Back to the current story

Version history

Judge rules against Agriculture Secretary Rollins over religious emails to USDA staff

1 published version. Every version stays readable at its own address, and nothing is removed without a correction note.

  1. Version 1Current · created

    First published.

    • Timeline added: On 4 July 2025, Rollins sent all USDA employees an Independence Day email from her official account that ended with a line asking God to protect the country, according to the ruling as quoted by Reason.
    • Timeline added: USDA issued guidance on religious expression on 20 November 2025, the ruling says, as quoted by Reason. It tells officials not to use their authority to pressure subordinates and to stop if a colleague asks.
    • Timeline added: On 26 November 2025, Rollins sent a Thanksgiving message to everyone at USDA from her official account, according to the ruling as quoted by Reason.
    • Timeline added: On 23 December 2025, Rollins emailed staff a Christmas message with a video, according to the ruling as quoted by Reason.
    • Timeline added: Her Easter message went out on 5 April 2026 to every member of USDA staff, according to the ruling as quoted by Reason.
    • Timeline added: The complaint was filed on 13 May, Fox News reported.
    • Timeline added: On 19 November, U.S. District Judge Trina Thompson decided against Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins in a dispute over messages to staff sent from her government email account, AP and Reuters reported. The two outlets were describing the same court order, so they are one account of it. Reason's Volokh Conspiracy published excerpts of the ruling the same day.
    • Confirmed: According to AP and Reuters, the judge found that the way the messages were written presented the secretary's Christian faith as if staff held it too.
    • Open question: The complaint was filed on 13 May, Fox News reported.
    • Open question: On 4 July 2025, Rollins sent all USDA employees an Independence Day email from her official account that ended with a line asking God to protect the country, according to the ruling as quoted by Reason.
    • Open question: USDA issued guidance on religious expression on 20 November 2025, the ruling says, as quoted by Reason. It tells officials not to use their authority to pressure subordinates and to stop if a colleague asks.
    • Open question: On 26 November 2025, Rollins sent a Thanksgiving message to everyone at USDA from her official account, according to the ruling as quoted by Reason.
    • Open question: On 23 December 2025, Rollins emailed staff a Christmas message with a video, according to the ruling as quoted by Reason.
    • Open question: Her Easter message went out on 5 April 2026 to every member of USDA staff, according to the ruling as quoted by Reason.
    • Open question: The judge singled out the Christmas and Easter messages as crossing the line, according to the excerpts Reason published.
    • Open question: The order requires the secretary to follow USDA's own rules for religious messages at work, Secretary's Memorandum 1078-019, according to Reason's excerpts. Under those rules she must stop if a colleague asks and may not use her authority to pressure staff.
    • Open question: The judge wrote that the court takes no position on what the secretary may do in her personal capacity, according to Reason's excerpts.
    • Open question: When the suit was filed, a USDA spokesperson told Fox News the department does not comment on pending cases and would keep the plaintiffs in its prayers.
    • Source added: Associated Press: USDA weighs appeal after judge rules against Rollins over religious emails to staff (The Associated Press)
    • Source added: Reuters: USDA weighs appeal after judge rules against Rollins over religious emails to staff (Reuters)
    • Source added: Expressly Christian Messages by Secretary of Agriculture to Employees Violated Establishment Clause, (Reason)
    • Source added: Federal employees accuse USDA secretary of 'Christian proselytizing' in holiday emails to staff (Fox News)