← Back to the current story

Version history

Fifth Circuit rules House proxy quorum unconstitutional, keeps Pregnant Workers Fairness Act blocked for Texas

1 published version. Every version stays readable at its own address, and nothing is removed without a correction note.

  1. Version 1Current · created

    First published.

    • Timeline added: On 15 May 2020, early in the COVID-19 pandemic, the House adopted House Resolution 965. It let a member act as proxy for an absent colleague, casting that colleague's vote or recording their presence, and counted those members toward a quorum. No member could hold proxies for more than 10 colleagues at once.
    • Timeline added: The House kept the proxy rule for the 117th Congress in 2021.
    • Timeline added: The House passed the spending act on 23 December 2022 by 225 votes to 201, with one member voting present and four not voting. There were 431 members serving that day because of four vacancies.
    • Timeline added: In 2024 the federal trial court in the Northern District of Texas ruled for Texas after a bench trial and issued a permanent order against enforcing the PWFA against the State. It did not block the rest of the act.
    • Timeline added: In 2025 a divided panel of the Fifth Circuit reversed that ruling and lifted the order, finding that the Quorum Clause does not require members to be physically present.
    • Timeline added: In 2026 the full Fifth Circuit agreed to rehear the case and set aside the panel's opinion.
    • Timeline added: On 20 November 2026 the full U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit held that the House broke the Constitution's Quorum Clause when it passed the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023 by counting absent members as present through proxies.
    • Confirmed: The judges split 9–8, Reuters and The Washington Post reported. The opinion lists Judge Cory T. Wilson as its author, joined by Chief Judge Elrod and seven other judges, with eight judges dissenting.
    • Confirmed: Texas is affected as an employer. The trial court found the law harmed the State through compliance costs as a regulated employer, the cost of defending federal investigations and lawsuits, and the loss of its immunity from suit.
    • Confirmed: On 15 May 2020, early in the COVID-19 pandemic, the House adopted House Resolution 965. It let a member act as proxy for an absent colleague, casting that colleague's vote or recording their presence, and counted those members toward a quorum. No member could hold proxies for more than 10 colleagues at once.
    • Confirmed: The House kept the proxy rule for the 117th Congress in 2021.
    • Confirmed: The House passed the spending act on 23 December 2022 by 225 votes to 201, with one member voting present and four not voting. There were 431 members serving that day because of four vacancies.
    • Confirmed: Of the 427 members who recorded a vote, 226 did so by proxy, a majority of the House, so fewer than half were physically in the chamber. The opinion says neither side disputes that a quorum existed only because proxies were counted.
    • Confirmed: The main dissent counts the same vote differently: 431 votes, 205 cast in person and 226 by proxy, against a quorum of 218 in a House of 435.
    • Confirmed: During the vote, Representative Chip Roy said no physical quorum was present and reserved the right to object. The presiding officer, Representative G.K. Butterfield, answered that under House rules a quorum was present, the opinion records.
    • Confirmed: After the Senate approved it too, the bill became law with the President's signature in 2022. The main dissent calls it a funding bill worth $1.7 trillion.
    • Confirmed: Texas sued to block two parts of the act: the PWFA and a $20 million payment to a Department of Homeland Security pilot program on alternatives to detention. The trial court found Texas had standing to challenge only the PWFA.
    • Confirmed: In 2024 the federal trial court in the Northern District of Texas ruled for Texas after a bench trial and issued a permanent order against enforcing the PWFA against the State. It did not block the rest of the act.
    • Confirmed: In 2025 a divided panel of the Fifth Circuit reversed that ruling and lifted the order, finding that the Quorum Clause does not require members to be physically present.
    • Confirmed: In 2026 the full Fifth Circuit agreed to rehear the case and set aside the panel's opinion.
    • Confirmed: The federal government argued that courts could not review the vote at all because of the enrolled-bill rule. Under that rule, a bill signed by the presiding officers of both chambers is treated as conclusive proof that it is genuine. As a fallback, it argued that the Quorum Clause allows presence by proxy, and it warned that a ruling for Texas would put the whole act at risk.
    • Confirmed: The majority rejected the enrolled-bill argument because Texas did not dispute any facts about how the bill passed, only what the Constitution requires. The main dissent agreed on that point.
    • Confirmed: The majority said the Constitution's text and history, and a Supreme Court ruling from 1892, show that members must actually be present to make up a quorum. In its words, "“Proxy presence” does not count."
    • Confirmed: Judge James E. Graves Jr. wrote the main dissent, joined by six judges. He argued that the Constitution's text, past practice and the framers' intent do not support a physical-presence rule, and that Congress used its power to set its own procedures during a pandemic. He called the majority's decision "illogical, inexplicable, and invalid."
    • Confirmed: The dissent also asked why, if the whole act was passed unconstitutionally, the judgment should cover only one small part of it.
    • Confirmed: Judge Haynes dissented in a short separate note, saying she did not think it right to throw out the House's action in this area.
    • Open question: The dissenting judges say Texas accepted millions of dollars under the same spending act while challenging one part of it. That is their description; the majority opinion does not make a finding on it.
    • Source added: https://www.ca5.uscourts.gov/opinions/pub/24/24-10386-CV1.pdf (United States Courts)
    • Source added: Reuters: Fifth Circuit upholds Texas injunction over House proxy voting (Reuters)
    • Source added: The Washington Post: Fifth Circuit upholds Texas injunction over House proxy voting (The Washington Post)