Version history
Agriculture Department delays its 2024 horse soring rule again, to 31 December 2027
- Version 1Current
First published.
- Timeline added: On 20 January 2017, a White House memo told agencies to pull back every rule still waiting to be published. APHIS withdrew a horse protection rule it had sent in nine days earlier, so it never appeared.
- Timeline added: On 13 August 2019, the Humane Society of the United States and other groups sued over that withdrawal, arguing it needed public notice and comment first. An appeals court agreed on 22 July 2022.
- Timeline added: On 21 August 2023, APHIS proposed the rule that became the 2024 rule. It would have APHIS screen, train and authorize the inspectors at covered events and ban action devices and non-therapeutic pads on Tennessee Walking Horses and racking horses. On 31 October 2023, APHIS formally withdrew the unpublished 2017 rule.
- Timeline added: On 8 May 2024, APHIS published the Horse Protection Amendments. Most of it was to start on 1 February 2025; one section, on training the new inspectors, took effect on 7 June 2024. The rule had APHIS screen, train and authorize the inspectors at every covered event, and took regulatory duties away from horse industry organizations.
- Timeline added: On 1 July 2024, the Tennessee Walking Horse National Celebration Association and two individuals sued over the rule in federal court in the Northern District of Texas. Their amended complaint argued the rule went beyond APHIS's legal powers and asked the court to throw it out.
- Timeline added: On 28 January 2025, APHIS made its first postponement, from 1 February 2025 to 2 April 2025, to hold things as they were while the lawsuit was pending.
- Timeline added: On 31 January 2025, the Texas court struck down the rule's ban on action devices, pads and substances, which it said went beyond APHIS's powers. It also struck down a new skin-condition test meant to replace the scar rule, and the rule's review steps, for lacking due process. It upheld the switch from industry-licensed designated qualified persons (DQPs) to Horse Protection Inspectors (HPIs).
- Timeline added: On 21 March 2025, APHIS moved the start date again, to 1 February 2026, and asked the public whether the delay should be longer. It said letting the remaining parts start on 2 April 2025 would be untenable for the agency and disruptive to the industry.
- Timeline added: That comment period ran 60 days and closed on 20 May 2025. APHIS received 6,124 submissions representing 93,734 comments, from members of Congress, state farm agencies, equine vets, animal welfare advocacy groups, horse owners, trainers and exhibitors, and others.
- Timeline added: On 30 June 2025, a second lawsuit in the same Texas court challenged rules already in force: the No-Showback Rule, which kept a noncompliant horse out of later classes at the same show, the scar rule, and the fairness of disqualifications based on USDA inspections.
- Timeline added: On 19 August 2025, the court blocked those rules for now. It found the No-Showback Rule and the scar rule likely go beyond the law, because the act requires disqualification only when a horse is sore at inspection, and that the inspection process likely lacks a chance to contest a decision first.
- Timeline added: On 28 January 2026, with that lawsuit still open, APHIS pushed the start date to 31 December 2026. It said the extra time would also let it finish reviewing a House committee report on the rule.
- Timeline added: On 28 August 2026, the Texas court ruled for the plaintiffs in the second case. It held that the No-Showback Rule and the scar rule exceed the department's authority and that its disqualification process lacks adequate due process.
- Timeline added: On 13 November 2026, APHIS proposed removing the struck-down parts of the 2024 rule, withdrawing the parts that survived, and updating the current rules instead. Comments are open for 30 days, until 14 December 2026, under docket APHIS-2026-0067.
- Timeline added: Dudley Hoskins, the department's Under Secretary for Marketing and Regulatory Programs, signed the delay in Washington on 18 November 2026. It was filed with the Federal Register on 20 November.
- Confirmed: Dudley Hoskins, the department's Under Secretary for Marketing and Regulatory Programs, signed the delay in Washington on 18 November 2026. It was filed with the Federal Register on 20 November.
- Confirmed: The delay takes effect at once. APHIS did not take public comment on it first, saying there was not enough time before the end of 2026 and that the need for regulatory clarity was good cause to skip that step.
- Confirmed: The Horse Protection Act aims to end soring and to keep competition fair. Under the law, a horse is sore when a person has used a blistering agent, a cut or burn, a tack or nail, or another substance, device or practice on its limbs, so that it suffers or can be expected to suffer pain, inflammation or lameness when it moves. Care given under a licensed veterinarian is excluded.
- Confirmed: The law requires the managers of horse shows and exhibitions to disqualify any sore horse. APHIS, an agency of the Agriculture Department, enforces the law through its Animal Care program.
- Confirmed: On 20 January 2017, a White House memo told agencies to pull back every rule still waiting to be published. APHIS withdrew a horse protection rule it had sent in nine days earlier, so it never appeared.
- Confirmed: On 13 August 2019, the Humane Society of the United States and other groups sued over that withdrawal, arguing it needed public notice and comment first. An appeals court agreed on 22 July 2022.
- Confirmed: On 21 August 2023, APHIS proposed the rule that became the 2024 rule. It would have APHIS screen, train and authorize the inspectors at covered events and ban action devices and non-therapeutic pads on Tennessee Walking Horses and racking horses. On 31 October 2023, APHIS formally withdrew the unpublished 2017 rule.
- Confirmed: On 8 May 2024, APHIS published the Horse Protection Amendments. Most of it was to start on 1 February 2025; one section, on training the new inspectors, took effect on 7 June 2024. The rule had APHIS screen, train and authorize the inspectors at every covered event, and took regulatory duties away from horse industry organizations.
- Confirmed: On 1 July 2024, the Tennessee Walking Horse National Celebration Association and two individuals sued over the rule in federal court in the Northern District of Texas. Their amended complaint argued the rule went beyond APHIS's legal powers and asked the court to throw it out.
- Confirmed: On 28 January 2025, APHIS made its first postponement, from 1 February 2025 to 2 April 2025, to hold things as they were while the lawsuit was pending.
- Confirmed: On 31 January 2025, the Texas court struck down the rule's ban on action devices, pads and substances, which it said went beyond APHIS's powers. It also struck down a new skin-condition test meant to replace the scar rule, and the rule's review steps, for lacking due process. It upheld the switch from industry-licensed designated qualified persons (DQPs) to Horse Protection Inspectors (HPIs).
- Confirmed: On 21 March 2025, APHIS moved the start date again, to 1 February 2026, and asked the public whether the delay should be longer. It said letting the remaining parts start on 2 April 2025 would be untenable for the agency and disruptive to the industry.
- Confirmed: That comment period ran 60 days and closed on 20 May 2025. APHIS received 6,124 submissions representing 93,734 comments, from members of Congress, state farm agencies, equine vets, animal welfare advocacy groups, horse owners, trainers and exhibitors, and others.
- Confirmed: On 30 June 2025, a second lawsuit in the same Texas court challenged rules already in force: the No-Showback Rule, which kept a noncompliant horse out of later classes at the same show, the scar rule, and the fairness of disqualifications based on USDA inspections.
- Confirmed: On 19 August 2025, the court blocked those rules for now. It found the No-Showback Rule and the scar rule likely go beyond the law, because the act requires disqualification only when a horse is sore at inspection, and that the inspection process likely lacks a chance to contest a decision first.
- Confirmed: On 28 January 2026, with that lawsuit still open, APHIS pushed the start date to 31 December 2026. It said the extra time would also let it finish reviewing a House committee report on the rule.
- Confirmed: In its report on the 2026 farm spending bill (H.R. Rep. 118-583), the House Appropriations Committee told APHIS to withdraw the 2024 rule. The committee said the rule exceeds the agency's authority and underestimates its effect on the 20,000 jobs it says the Tennessee Walking Horse industry supports.
- Confirmed: On 28 August 2026, the Texas court ruled for the plaintiffs in the second case. It held that the No-Showback Rule and the scar rule exceed the department's authority and that its disqualification process lacks adequate due process.
- Confirmed: The proposal would keep inspectors licensed through industry groups but make them renew their license every 5 years, repeating 14 hours of training. Two APHIS vets would have to agree before a horse is found noncompliant, individuals who are responsible for a horse could appeal at once to a neutral official at the event, the scar rule would go, and masking agents such as sedatives or topical numbing agents would be banned. A sore horse would miss only the class where it was inspected, not the whole event.
- Confirmed: Shows would need at least two of these inspectors once more than 100 horses are entered, down from more than 150 now.
- Confirmed: The proposal also records past criticism of the industry inspectors. A 2021 National Academies study it quotes warned that conflicts of interest may sway their decisions on whether a horse complies, a concern the USDA Office of Inspector General had also raised. APHIS says its stricter training and conduct rules are meant to answer those concerns.
- Confirmed: APHIS had estimated that the 2024 rule could raise its own costs by up to $3.2 million a year. It now expects withdrawing the rule to have a negligible economic impact, mainly because APHIS, not the industry, was to pay for the rule's main new costs.
- Open question: Whether APHIS will adopt its proposal, and when, is not yet known. It says the delay gives it time to review the comments and, if appropriate, issue a final rule.
- Source added: Federal Register, Volume 91 Issue 224 (Monday, November 23, 2026) (U.S. Government Publishing Office (govinfo))
- Source added: Federal Register, Volume 91 Issue 218 (Friday, November 13, 2026) (U.S. Government Publishing Office (govinfo))