The full Fifth Circuit has kept federal agencies from enforcing the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act against Texas, ruling that the House's December 2022 proxy quorum was unconstitutional.
Topics ยท Topic record
Courts
This page is assembled from the stories below. Every line comes from a story's current version and links to the source it cites.
Where things stand
- Fifth Circuit rules House proxy quorum unconstitutional, keeps Pregnant Workers Fairness Act blocked for Texas
The full Fifth Circuit has kept federal agencies from enforcing the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act against Texas, ruling that the House's December 2022 proxy quorum was unconstitutional.
- DevelopingJudge rules against Agriculture Secretary Rollins over religious emails to USDA staff
A federal judge has ruled against Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins over religious emails to staff, and the department said it may appeal, AP and Reuters reported.
- DevelopingJustice Department moves to end its lawsuit over Alaska's Senate certification
The Justice Department has asked an appeals court to end its own lawsuit that sought to hold up certification of Alaska's Senate race, the Washington Examiner and AP reported.
- DevelopingJudge lets part of Trump's $15 billion suit against The New York Times go forward
A federal judge has let Donald Trump's claims over the book Lucky Loser go ahead against The New York Times, but threw out claims over two Times articles.
Key facts
- On 20 November 2026 the full U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit held that the House broke the Constitution's Quorum Clause when it passed the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023 by counting absent members as present through proxies. United States Courts
- The court upheld a lower-court order that bars the federal government from enforcing the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act (PWFA) against the State of Texas. United States Courts, Reuters, The Washington Post
- The majority stressed that the order is narrow. It blocks only enforcement of the PWFA, only against Texas, and the court said its decision goes no further than upholding that relief. United States Courts
- On 19 November, U.S. District Judge Trina Thompson decided against Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins in a dispute over messages to staff sent from her government email account, AP and Reuters reported. The two outlets were describing the same court order, so they are one account of it. Reason's Volokh Conspiracy published excerpts of the ruling the same day. The Associated Press, Reuters, Reason
- The department objected to the ruling's limits on what the secretary can send and said it was weighing an appeal, AP and Reuters reported. The Associated Press, Reuters
- The case is National Federation of Federal Employees v. U.S. Department of Agriculture, in the federal court for the Northern District of California, according to Reason's Volokh Conspiracy. Fox News reported in May that the union brought the complaint in that court together with seven USDA employees. Reason, Fox News
- On Thursday, 19 November, the Justice Department moved to drop its own case, the Washington Examiner reported. AP reported that the filing asked the Ninth Circuit appeals court to throw out the department's challenge to Alaska's Senate certification. Washington Examiner, The Associated Press
- The department had sued to delay certification while it looked into whether voters confused the Republican senator, Dan Sullivan, with another candidate on the ballot who has a similar name, Fox News and AP reported. Fox News, The Associated Press
- On Sunday, 1 November, two days before Election Day, U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason dismissed the department's lawsuit, Fox News and the Washington Examiner reported. Fox News, Washington Examiner, Fox News
- Judge Steven Merryday, a federal judge in Tampa, let Trump's claims over the book Lucky Loser move forward toward a possible trial, turning down the Times' request to dismiss the whole case, Fox News and the Washington Examiner reported. Washington Examiner, Fox News
- The suit, which seeks $15 billion, names The New York Times and Penguin Random House, the book's publisher, according to both outlets. Washington Examiner, Fox News
- In July 2026, the judge gave Trump's lawyers until 27 August to amend the suit again and put off ruling on the Times' motion to dismiss, Fox News and the Washington Examiner reported. Washington Examiner, Fox News
Timeline
- On 20 November 2026 the full U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit held that the House broke the Constitution's Quorum Clause when it passed the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023 by counting absent members as present through proxies. United States Courts
- On 19 November, U.S. District Judge Trina Thompson decided against Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins in a dispute over messages to staff sent from her government email account, AP and Reuters reported. The two outlets were describing the same court order, so they are one account of it. Reason's Volokh Conspiracy published excerpts of the ruling the same day. The Associated Press, Reuters, Reason
- On Thursday, 19 November, the Justice Department moved to drop its own case, the Washington Examiner reported. AP reported that the filing asked the Ninth Circuit appeals court to throw out the department's challenge to Alaska's Senate certification. Washington Examiner, The Associated Press
- Judge Steven Merryday, a federal judge in Tampa, let Trump's claims over the book Lucky Loser move forward toward a possible trial, turning down the Times' request to dismiss the whole case, Fox News and the Washington Examiner reported. Washington Examiner, Fox News
- The department filed a notice of appeal after the dismissal, saying the judge had decided the case on procedural grounds, Fox News reported. Fox News, Fox News
- On Sunday, 1 November, two days before Election Day, U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason dismissed the department's lawsuit, Fox News and the Washington Examiner reported. Fox News, Washington Examiner, Fox News
- In July 2026, the judge gave Trump's lawyers until 27 August to amend the suit again and put off ruling on the Times' motion to dismiss, Fox News and the Washington Examiner reported. Washington Examiner, Fox News
- In July 2026, the judge ruled that the case could stay in the Middle District of Florida rather than move to New York, Reason reported. Reason
- The complaint was filed on 13 May, Fox News reported. Fox News
- Her Easter message went out on 5 April 2026 to every member of USDA staff, according to the ruling as quoted by Reason. Reason
- In 2026 the full Fifth Circuit agreed to rehear the case and set aside the panel's opinion. United States Courts
- On 23 December 2025, Rollins emailed staff a Christmas message with a video, according to the ruling as quoted by Reason. Reason
- On 26 November 2025, Rollins sent a Thanksgiving message to everyone at USDA from her official account, according to the ruling as quoted by Reason. Reason
- USDA issued guidance on religious expression on 20 November 2025, the ruling says, as quoted by Reason. It tells officials not to use their authority to pressure subordinates and to stop if a colleague asks. Reason
- Trump refiled a 40-page amended complaint in the federal court in Tampa in October 2025, Fox News reported. It named the Times, reporters Craig, Buettner and Baker, and Penguin Random House, and dropped reporter Michael S. Schmidt. Fox News
- In September 2025, days after the filing, Judge Merryday struck the first complaint for its length and gave Trump's team 28 days to file one of no more than 40 pages, according to Reason and Fox News. Reason, Fox News
- Trump first filed the $15 billion defamation suit against The New York Times in September 2025, The Daily Caller reported; the original complaint ran to 85 pages, according to Fox News and Reason. The Daily Caller, Fox News, Reason
- On 4 July 2025, Rollins sent all USDA employees an Independence Day email from her official account that ended with a line asking God to protect the country, according to the ruling as quoted by Reason. Reason
- In 2025 a divided panel of the Fifth Circuit reversed that ruling and lifted the order, finding that the Quorum Clause does not require members to be physically present. United States Courts
- In 2024 the federal trial court in the Northern District of Texas ruled for Texas after a bench trial and issued a permanent order against enforcing the PWFA against the State. It did not block the rest of the act. United States Courts
- The House passed the spending act on 23 December 2022 by 225 votes to 201, with one member voting present and four not voting. There were 431 members serving that day because of four vacancies. United States Courts
- The House kept the proxy rule for the 117th Congress in 2021. United States Courts
- On 15 May 2020, early in the COVID-19 pandemic, the House adopted House Resolution 965. It let a member act as proxy for an absent colleague, casting that colleague's vote or recording their presence, and counted those members toward a quorum. No member could hold proxies for more than 10 colleagues at once. United States Courts
Stories in this record
A federal judge has ruled against Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins over religious emails to staff, and the department said it may appeal, AP and Reuters reported.
The Justice Department has asked an appeals court to end its own lawsuit that sought to hold up certification of Alaska's Senate race, the Washington Examiner and AP reported.
A federal judge has let Donald Trump's claims over the book Lucky Loser go ahead against The New York Times, but threw out claims over two Times articles.