Judge lets part of Trump's $15 billion suit against The New York Times go forward
A federal judge has let Donald Trump's claims over the book Lucky Loser go ahead against The New York Times, but threw out claims over two Times articles.
Based so far on 4 news outlets. 8 points are not yet confirmed.

A federal judge in Tampa, Florida, on Thursday let part of President Donald Trump's defamation suit against The New York Times go ahead, Fox News and the Washington Examiner reported. Claims over the book Lucky Loser, by Times reporters Russ Buettner and Susanne Craig, can continue against the paper and the publisher Penguin Random House. Claims over two Times articles were dismissed, the Washington Examiner reported.
Key facts
- Judge Steven Merryday, a federal judge in Tampa, let Trump's claims over the book Lucky Loser move forward toward a possible trial, turning down the Times' request to dismiss the whole case, Fox News and the Washington Examiner reported. [1] [2]
- The suit, which seeks $15 billion, names The New York Times and Penguin Random House, the book's publisher, according to both outlets. [1] [2]
- In July 2026, the judge gave Trump's lawyers until 27 August to amend the suit again and put off ruling on the Times' motion to dismiss, Fox News and the Washington Examiner reported. [7] [8]
Timeline
- In July 2026, the judge ruled that the case could stay in the Middle District of Florida rather than move to New York, Reason reported. [6]
- Trump refiled a 40-page amended complaint in the federal court in Tampa in October 2025, Fox News reported. It named the Times, reporters Craig, Buettner and Baker, and Penguin Random House, and dropped reporter Michael S. Schmidt. [4]
What we know
- Trump first filed the $15 billion defamation suit against The New York Times in September 2025, The Daily Caller reported; the original complaint ran to 85 pages, according to Fox News and Reason. [3] [4] [5]
- In September 2025, days after the filing, Judge Merryday struck the first complaint for its length and gave Trump's team 28 days to file one of no more than 40 pages, according to Reason and Fox News. [5] [4]
What we don't know yet
- The Washington Examiner reported that the judge dismissed the claims over two Times articles: one by Buettner and Craig, and one by Peter Baker, the paper's chief White House correspondent. [1]
- Fox News reported that four counts, resting on seven specific statements, may go ahead, while two counts were dismissed and 27 other challenged statements were ruled not actionable under the First Amendment standard from New York Times Co. v. Sullivan. [2]
- The judge also refused to let Trump rewrite his complaint once more, Fox News reported. [2]
- According to Fox News, the judge gave the Times 28 days to file its formal answer to the claims that remain. [2]
- A spokesman for Trump's legal team told Fox News that the judge had "correctly denied" the motion and that the defendants "will now have to answer" for the claims. [2]
- A Times spokesperson told Fox News the paper was encouraged that the judge had dismissed "almost all claims" and that it still believes the remaining claim has "no legal merit". [2]
- Trump refiled a 40-page amended complaint in the federal court in Tampa in October 2025, Fox News reported. It named the Times, reporters Craig, Buettner and Baker, and Penguin Random House, and dropped reporter Michael S. Schmidt. [4]
- In July 2026, the judge ruled that the case could stay in the Middle District of Florida rather than move to New York, Reason reported. [6]
Why it matters
The suit asks for $15 billion. This ruling decides which parts of it survive the first stage of the case. Neither report says the judge ruled on whether the book's statements were true. Fox News reported that the judge ordered the Times to file a formal answer within 28 days. The Washington Examiner reported that the book claims can move forward to a possible trial.
Questions
Can Trump's $15 billion lawsuit against The New York Times go to trial?
Part of it can. The Washington Examiner reported that the claims over the book Lucky Loser can move forward toward a possible trial, while claims over two Times articles were dismissed. No trial date has been reported.
Did the judge decide whether the book was accurate?
Neither report says the judge ruled on whether the book's statements were true. Both describe a ruling on which claims can continue.
What did the judge throw out?
According to the Washington Examiner, the claims over two Times articles, one by Buettner and Craig and one by Peter Baker. Fox News reported that two counts were dismissed and 27 other challenged statements were ruled not actionable.
What happens next in the case?
Fox News reported that the Times must file a formal answer within 28 days of the ruling, and that the judge refused to let Trump amend his complaint again.
What have the two sides said?
Trump's legal team told Fox News the motion was "correctly denied". A Times spokesperson told Fox News the paper believes the remaining claim has "no legal merit".
Updates
- First published.
Every version of this story, as first published.
Sources
- Washington Examiner News organizationPublished: 19 November 2026Retrieved: 20 November 2026
- Fox News News organizationPublished: 20 November 2026Retrieved: 20 November 2026
- The Daily Caller News organizationPublished: 16 September 2025Retrieved: 20 November 2026
- Fox News News organizationPublished: 17 October 2025Retrieved: 20 November 2026
- Reason News organizationPublished: 19 September 2025Retrieved: 20 November 2026
- Reason News organizationPublished: 6 July 2026Retrieved: 20 November 2026
- Washington Examiner News organizationPublished: 28 July 2026Retrieved: 20 November 2026
- Fox News News organizationPublished: 27 July 2026Retrieved: 20 November 2026
About the picture: this is an illustration made for this story with an AI image tool and checked against it. It is not a picture of the real people, places or events.
People, places and organizations
- Person
- Donald Trump
- Organization
- The New York Times Company
- Organization
- Penguin Random House
- Person
- Steven D. Merryday
- Product
- Lucky Loser
Follow us on Facebook
We post new records on our Facebook Page.
Follow on Facebook